Supreme Court Changes Deprivation of Liberty Test as Applications Reach 380,000

A landmark Supreme Court ruling has changed how deprivation of liberty is assessed across the UK, raising important questions about the rights of people living in care homes, hospitals and supported accommodation.

The judgment, handed down on 2 June 2026, overturned a legal test used for more than a decade to determine when someone was being deprived of their liberty. The change comes as new government figures reveal that 380,715 applications were made under the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS) in England during 2025-26, an increase of 4.3% on the previous year.

The figures, published by the Department of Health and Social Care on 5 November 2026, highlight the scale of decisions being made about the freedom and care arrangements of adults who may lack the mental capacity to make certain decisions for themselves.

Although the statistics cover a period ending before the Supreme Court judgment, they indicate the number of cases that could be affected by the change in legal interpretation.

Supreme Court abandons the long-standing deprivation of liberty test

The ruling represents a significant change to the interpretation of Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to liberty and security.

Previously, the 2014 Cheshire West judgment established what became known as the acid test. Under that approach, a person was considered deprived of their liberty if they were under continuous supervision and control and not free to leave, and lacked the mental capacity to consent to those arrangements.

The Supreme Court has now ruled that this approach was too simplistic. Instead, decisions must consider the individual circumstances of each person, including the nature and duration of restrictions, their effect on the individual and how they are implemented.

A person’s wishes and feelings must also carry significant weight. Importantly, the 2026 judgment clarified that someone who lacks mental capacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 may still be capable of giving valid consent to their living arrangements for the purposes of Article 5.

However, compliance should not automatically be treated as consent. Where there is serious doubt about whether someone understands and accepts their circumstances, valid consent cannot simply be assumed.

The new interpretation applies immediately across the UK, placing fresh responsibilities on care providers, local authorities and healthcare professionals when reviewing restrictive care arrangements.

More than 380,000 applications highlight the scale of DoLS decisions

The latest figures show that England received 380,715 DoLS applications between April 2025 and March 2026, compared with 364,900 in the previous reporting year.

Of the 372,145 applications completed during the period, 168,995 received a full assessment. A further 16,015 were partially assessed, while 187,130 were closed without any assessment.

The distinction is important. Closing an application without assessment does not necessarily mean an authorisation was wrongly granted or that a person’s rights were disregarded. The published figures do not establish the individual reasons behind every closure.

Nevertheless, the volume of applications highlights the administrative pressures involved in identifying and reviewing cases where restrictions may amount to a deprivation of liberty. There are also questions around processing times. Only 22.8% of standard applications were completed within the statutory 21-day period. The average completion time across all completed applications was 117 days, down from 126 days in 2024-25.

DoLS applies to adults who lack the relevant capacity to consent to care arrangements in hospitals and registered care homes. It provides a legal framework for authorising restrictions where the requirements are met, and an independent assessment establishes that the arrangements are justified.

The system also gives individuals and their representatives rights to request reviews and challenge authorisations.

Section 21A challenges allow families to question restrictions

One important protection under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 is Section 21A, which allows a person subject to a standard or urgent DoLS authorisation to ask the Court of Protection to review the arrangements.

A challenge may concern whether the person meets the qualifying requirements, whether the length of an authorisation is justified or whether the conditions imposed are appropriate.

For example, relatives may question whether a family member needs the level of supervision currently imposed, whether a care home remains the right place for them to live or whether less restrictive alternatives have been properly considered.

The court can examine the relevant issues and has powers to vary or terminate a standard authorisation. It can also consider whether an urgent authorisation should have been granted.

The distinction between mental capacity law and housing law is particularly important when seeking legal assistance. Someone looking for asolicitor for a Section 21 notice in this context needs to distinguish a Section 21A challenge under the Mental Capacity Act from a landlord’s Section 21 notice under the Housing Act 1988. They are separate legal procedures, despite the similar terminology.

A Section 21A application concerns whether restrictions on someone’s liberty are lawful and justified. It can be brought by the person concerned or, in certain circumstances, their Relevant Person’s Representative.

Wider care disputes can involve the Court of Protection

Not every disagreement about a vulnerable person’s care is limited to a DoLS authorisation.

Families may disagree with local authorities or healthcare professionals about where someone should live, whether particular medical treatment is appropriate or how much contact they should have with relatives.

These issues can require a broader examination of the person’s welfare under the Mental Capacity Act 2005.

The Court of Protection has jurisdiction to make decisions on behalf of people who lack the relevant mental capacity. Its responsibilities extend beyond deprivation of liberty to matters involving residence, medical treatment, personal welfare and relationships.

The court may also become involved where someone is living in supported accommodation or another community setting rather than a registered care home or hospital. In these circumstances, where the arrangements amount to a deprivation of liberty, the relevant authorisation must come through the court rather than the standard DoLS process.

Recent court statistics illustrate the continuing demand for judicial oversight. Between April and June 2026, the Court of Protection received 1,864 applications relating to deprivation of liberty under the Mental Capacity Act, 13% fewer than in the same quarter of 2025.

These figures measure applications made to the court, rather than the much larger number of DoLS applications submitted to local authorities. They should therefore not be treated as directly comparable.

Disputes can become particularly complicated when several parties have different views about what is best for the individual. Medical professionals may recommend continued supervision, while relatives believe that the restrictions are excessive or that alternative care arrangements should be explored.

A specialistcourt of protection lawyer can assist with these disagreements, including applications concerning residence, welfare, treatment and challenges to deprivation of liberty arrangements.

Existing authorisations face a period of review

The government has acknowledged that the Supreme Court judgment could have significant implications for people already subject to DoLS authorisations.

Some individuals may no longer fall within the legal definition of deprivation of liberty following the revised assessment. Local authorities have therefore been advised to review existing cases as soon as reasonably practicable.

However, the government has also clarified that an existing authorisation remaining in place during this review period does not automatically mean that the person is being unlawfully deprived of their liberty.

Importantly, the judgment does not remove the need for legal safeguards. Where Article 5 applies, the relevant authorisation and review procedures must still be followed. Independent advocacy and the involvement of a Relevant Person’s Representative also remain important protections.

The longer-term impact of the ruling is expected to include a reduction in the number of deprivation of liberty authorisations. However, how quickly that happens will depend on how consistently local authorities, care providers and courts apply the new approach.

For families, the central issue remains whether care arrangements respect an individual’s rights, wishes and personal circumstances. The latest judgment changes the legal framework for answering that question, but it does not remove the need for independent scrutiny when someone’s freedom is restricted.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *